Featured Dialogue: 50th Anniversary of the Historic Preservation Act

30 Sep 2015 2:49 PM | Christine R Henry

by Gretchen Buggeln, Valparaiso University, VAF President

The Chicago VAF conference this past June began with an excellent and provocative lecture by Professor Davarian Baldwin that centered on the fate of Chicago’s Checkerboard Lounge blues club. In the Q&A following the talk, Louis Nelson, architectural historian at the University of Virginia, raised important questions about the way we think about historic preservation in the United States, the language of the Historic Preservation Act of 1966, and whether VAF members could and should push for a new definition of historic preservation. Nelson's remarks sparked a lively conversation that rippled through the conference.

Professor Baldwin graciously agreed to let us reprint a portion of his June lecture in this issue of the VAN. In addition, I've asked three VAF members to respond. First, Louis Nelson reiterates his questions and critique. Jennifer Baughn, Architectural Historian for the State of Mississippi, responds with a current practitioner's perspective.  Finally, Jennifer Cousineau will adds Canadian perspective.  We hope that this online conversation will elicit your engagement. Please join in!

Comments

  • 31 Jul 2024 9:55 AM | Robert W. Craig
    I've long felt that the definitions or qualities or aspects of "integrity" were too narrowly drawn in NHPA. The seven qualities: location, setting, design, materials, etc., ... are all measures that relate to individual buildings exclusively.

    There are no measures that contribute to any sense of collective integrity. I would propose consideration of the following, for example.

    integrity of incidence. - the degree to which a building importantly contributes to the incidence of survival of the resources of its type or context, such that that incidence would more closely match the incidence of resources of its type in its historic period.

    Integrity of range. - the degree to which a resource importantly reflects the geographic range within which such resources occurred during their historic period. (Unusual survivals near the outer edges of the historic range, for example, might rate higher on this measure than ones in the heart of the range.)

    Integrity of distribution. - a measure of the degree to which a resource helps to reflect the geographic distribution that its type of resources displayed during their historic period.

    Bob Craig
    rcraig@advancedoldbuildingresearch.com
    www.advancedoldbuildingresearch.com
    Link  •  Reply
© Vernacular Architecture Forum

For more information or questions contact
the secretary or the webmaster.

Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software